Reference · Article 6

Litigation Funding and Governance Implications

Third-party funding in Swiss disputes and the board decisions that bear on it.

Status
First edition · 2026-05-05
First published
2026-05-05
Last reviewed
2026-05-05

Third-party funding raises questions about cost, control, confidentiality and the allocation of recoveries. Swiss law permits commercial litigation funding within applicable contractual and professional limits. This article explains the legal baseline and practical questions for companies considering funding or facing a funded claim. It distinguishes commercial funding from creditor pursuit of claims under Art. 260 SchKG.

1. The doctrinal baseline

In BGE 131 I 223 of 10 December 2004, the Federal Supreme Court held that a categorical cantonal ban on commercial litigation funding was incompatible with economic freedom. The judgment considers the client’s interests, counsel’s professional duties and contractual limits. It does not prohibit every funder consent right or guarantee the claimant unrestricted control. Review the actual funding terms and the procedural rules applicable to the dispute.

The permissibility is not unconditional. Swiss doctrine superimposes on the basic freedom a set of safeguards designed to preserve the integrity of the claimant–counsel relationship and the administration of justice.

Control of the claim. Funding terms can limit the claimant’s practical freedom, including through settlement consent and termination provisions. These terms require careful review against the client’s interests, counsel’s independence and general contractual limits. BGE 131 I 223, consid. 4.5.5 and 4.6.2–4.6.6, does not impose a blanket prohibition on funder consent rights.

Counsel’s independence and fees. Funding does not remove counsel’s duties under Art. 12 BGFA. Pure contingency arrangements and advance promises to waive fees on an unsuccessful outcome are prohibited by paragraph (e). A success premium added to a fee payable regardless of outcome can be permissible, but BGE 143 III 600, consid. 2.7.5, requires a base fee covering costs and a reasonable profit, a premium that does not undermine independence or create a risk of overreaching, and agreement at the start of the mandate or after the dispute ends. A premium exceeding the base fee clearly crosses the limit; the Court did not set a universal permitted percentage. The conditions were reiterated in 4A_40/2023, consid. 6.1.

Disclosure. Check the applicable procedural rules, arbitration rules and directions before deciding what funding information must be disclosed. Distinguish identifying a funder for conflict checks from producing the funding agreement or its terms. Do not assume that either all funding arrangements must be disclosed or all their terms can be withheld.

2. Funding structures and where they apply

Consider the following arrangements separately; their legal and commercial effects depend on the terms.

Single-case funding. A funder may finance the costs of pursuing a claim in return for a contractually defined share of recovery. Review which costs are included, who owns the claim, the funder’s return and any protection against adverse costs. Those features depend on the agreement.

Portfolio funding. An arrangement may cover several claims rather than one. Review how recoveries, costs, risk and termination rights are allocated across the portfolio, and whether one claim’s result affects another. This structure should not be assumed to suit a particular claimant or law firm without examining the terms.

Claims pursued after bankruptcy. Art. 260 SchKG allows creditors to obtain authority to pursue claims that the creditors collectively have declined to pursue. It does not transfer ownership of the claim, and any commercial funding arrangement is a separate matter. In 4A_62/2024, the Canton of Zurich pursued assigned director-liability claims. The judgment does not establish that a commercial third-party funder financed the action.

Funding a defence. Where external finance is proposed for defence costs, examine the repayment or return mechanism, any interaction with insurance, settlement rights and control over counsel and strategy. Do not infer the allocation of control from the label of the arrangement.

3. When the company is the claimant

A funding arrangement may be material to the company because it affects costs, recoveries and control over a claim. Assess the actual financial commitments, conditions and risks rather than assuming that the arrangement guarantees funding or transfers every litigation risk.

Structuring questions. What is the funder’s return profile, and at what recovery levels does the company retain a material share? What are the drawdown conditions, and what happens if the claim is lost or withdrawn? What are the termination rights, and on what grounds may either side exit? What is the adverse-costs protection, and how does it interact with the funder’s ability to terminate?

Control questions. Identify consent rights over settlement, counsel and the scope of the claim, together with termination rights and their consequences. Assess whether the terms protect the company’s interests and remain compatible with counsel’s professional duties. A funder’s consent right is not automatically prohibited; its content and practical effect matter.

Disclosure and privilege. Decide what information the funder needs for diligence and during the case. Obtain any necessary client consent, limit disclosure and agree confidentiality terms. Disclosure requires a separate assessment under the applicable Swiss and foreign procedural rules. A common-interest label does not by itself establish protection. BGE 131 I 223, consid. 4.5.6, addresses consent to disclosure, not a general common-interest privilege.

Accounting and tax. Assess the accounting and tax treatment of the actual arrangement before commitment, including the treatment of payments, obligations and recoveries. Involve the company’s advisers where needed; labels such as funding, proceeds participation or loan do not settle the treatment.

Board process. Establish the competent decision-maker under the company’s organisation and the significance of the funding arrangement. For a substantial claim, the board should understand the material terms, alternatives and risks and document the reasons for the chosen course. Lawful delegation does not remove retained oversight responsibilities.

4. When the company is the defendant

Funding may affect the resources and incentives behind a claim. The board should assess what is known about the arrangement without assuming the opponent is well capitalised or committed to a long contest.

Resources and incentives. A funding arrangement may affect the claimant’s resources and settlement incentives. Its terms, funding limits and termination rights matter. Do not assume either that the claimant can be exhausted by costs or that funding makes it immune to cost pressure. Assess the merits and the available procedural options.

Settlement dynamics. Funding terms may affect the distribution of a settlement and who must consent. Where reliable information is available, consider these constraints alongside the merits, remaining costs and alternatives. Money already spent does not by itself determine whether a funder favours continuing or settling.

Information about funding. The opponent’s funding terms may be unknown. Before seeking disclosure, identify the legal basis, the material fact to be established and the applicable protections. Art. 99 ZPO regulates security for party costs under specified conditions; the mere existence of funding does not itself establish entitlement to security or production of the full agreement. Arbitration conflict checks require analysis under the applicable rules.

5. Insolvency and Art. 260 SchKG

Under Art. 260 SchKG, creditors may request authority to pursue estate claims that the creditors collectively have declined to pursue. They litigate at their own risk. Under paragraph 2, recovery after costs first satisfies the claims of the assigned creditors according to their rank; any surplus goes to the estate. An Art. 260 assignment does not itself establish that a commercial third-party funder is involved.

A company’s bankruptcy does not itself end directors’ liability exposure. The Papierschlamm decision illustrates creditor pursuit of liability claims after bankruptcy through Art. 260 SchKG. The availability of that procedure should be distinguished from commercial litigation funding and from the limitation rules governing the underlying claim.

Plan preservation and access to relevant records with possible later claims in mind, including claims pursued after bankruptcy. Check the actual retention duties and arrangements for custody and access; continued operation of the company should not be the only plan.

6. What this means for boards

Three practical points follow.

If funding a claim, review the terms. For a substantial claim, compare available arrangements, assess the funder’s ability to meet its commitments and negotiate control, termination and disclosure provisions. Obtain approval from the competent body and ensure appropriate reporting to the board.

If facing a funded claim, assess the merits. Funding does not establish the opponent’s resources, sophistication or tolerance for costs. Assess the claim and defence on the evidence and review settlement options in light of the information actually available.

Remember Art. 260. Creditors may pursue assigned claims after bankruptcy if the statutory conditions are met. Commercial funding is possible but is not a condition of the procedure. Keep records and assess liability and limitation questions on their merits; neither bankruptcy nor the absence of a known funder establishes that a claim will not be pursued.

See also

Selected primary sources